19

Apr

12:21am
Mxolisi Ncube Zimbabwe
THE NEW SCRAMBLE FOR AFRICA: What it means for Africa’s human rights record

THE NEW SCRAMBLE FOR AFRICA: What it means for Africa’s human rights record

Mxolisi Ncube Zimbabwe//12:21am, Apr 19th '23

The Russia-Ukraine war has widened the rift between the entrenched West and the emerging East and – as collateral damage ⸺ Africa’s already sordid human rights record will regress further. According to Statista, a leading provider of market and consumer data, eight African states rank among the world’s 15 countries with the worst human rights and rule of law records as of 2022. Of course, such ratings are sometimes controversial, subjective and drafted with certain agendas in mind, but even that is on its own a strong indicator of how ordinary Africans are set to continue bearing the brunt of the geopolitical fights between especially China/Russia on one hand and the West on the other. Many African countries have gone decades into a new life, after they attained their independence from Western nations, with the help of either or both China and the then Union of Soviet Socialist Republic (Russia). Many have also sought to break free from the political influence and economic reliance of the former colonial master, turning their focus to China, India and Russia.

It is quite telling then, that China and Russia both feature in the top 15 Statista list, with none of the Western superpowers appearing, despite racism and hostile foreign policies being part of their governance and domination strategy.

Panellists at a seminar dubbed “The State of Human Rights in Africa”, held at the Egrek Cinema in Parkhurst, Johannesburg on 23rd March 2023, almost unanimously agreed that, while African governments came short in fulfilling their human rights obligations to their citizens, a Western hand cannot be ruled out completely from those who keep on spoiling the broth.

While converging in the argument that the concept of human rights extends beyond victims of civil strife and the mere process of holding elections which propel politicians to power, to the provision of basic services to citizens, the panellists added that the West did also set the wrong foundation for post independence Africa.

Without trying to absolve the actions of African governments, human rights lawyer Magdalene Moonsamy argued that the violation of human rights in Africa was a colonial construct.

“...human rights is just a muzzle tool of colonial character to counteract its ability to be taken to task for its wrongness. And I think when we understand and go into the history of what happened in African history collectively, we will appreciate that, you know we look at the situation in South Sudan ⸺ there is peace today, there is war tomorrow; the husband and wife get kicked out of the cabinet. There is absolutely no government, there is no accountability,” said Moonsamy.

Of the many disparities of colonial rule in Africa, the same colonial master who still seeks to police international affairs and run the rule on human rights and good governance has left no space for restitution. Resultantly, it has been difficult for many an African government to correct what former Zimbabwean President, Robert Mugabe termed “the imbalances of the past”.

If you read our blogs then why not our magazine!!!
Image
Click here to subscribe our monthly magazine

Zimbabwe, for all of ZANU(PF)’s failings, is one good example of a corrective situation gone wrong with the aid of the West. In 2000, Mugabe embarked on a land reform exercise which he claimed was meant to redistribute land to a landless black majority dispossessed by the colonial regime. Riding on the human rights abuses which followed the land reform programmes, the USA struck Zimbabwe with sanctions in the form of the Zimbabwe Democracy and Economic Recovery Act (ZiDERA), which cuts balance of payment support to the Southern African country and directs governors of US banks sitting on any board of a Bretton-Woods institution to block lending and debt relief to Zimbabwe.

Mugabe’s own hand in the resultant political and economic melee cannot be ruled out though as, in a bid to address the human rights deficiency in terms of equal access to land, he allowed war veterans, ZANU(PF) supporters and youth militias to go on an orgy of violence, resulting in the brutal murder of at least five white commercial farmers, displacement of many others and the laying off of thousands of black farm workers. He had politicised and racialised the land redistribution exercise, giving a sorry view of how a government’s fight with the West can affect ordinary citizens.

Having politicised what was otherwise a genuine land restitution exercise, Mugabe suddenly fell from the erstwhile African poster boy of the West to be one of the most hated African leaders. Zimbabwe has now effectively been politically divided into two ⸺ a failing ruling party claiming to be friends with China on one hand and a hostile mainstream opposition with Western backing on the other. Meanwhile, ordinary Zimbabweans continue to suffer, with their country now one of the highest migrant producing countries as its economy has literally crumbled during the last two decades. The East versus West fight, however, does not begin and end with Zimbabwe. The USA recently ordered South Africa to stop doing military drills with Russia and start engaging the USA instead, as the fallout from the Russia-Ukraine war continues to affect African states.

A few weeks later, as South Africa prepares to host the August 2023 BRICS Summit, the International Criminal Court (ICC) levelled war crimes charges against Russian President Vladimir Putin. The crimes, which include allegations of the kidnapping of Ukrainian children during the ongoing war, are meant to further checkmate Pretoria’s relations with Russia ahead of the BRICS Summit.

One thing for certain though is that the East versus West fight, coupled with what has been seen as the “New Scramble for Africa”, will have a huge bearing on the human rights situation of African citizens. Economic measures, Western-sponsored opposition parties, media houses and non-profit organisations on the one hand and vindictive governments on the other, are likely to trample on the rights of ordinary citizens while fighting against each other.

This article war first published in The African Mirror

Editor's Note:

The views and informations expressed in the article are solely those of the author and may or may not reflect the views of The International. We believe in providing a platform for a range of viewpoints from the left.

‘‘Inequality, Capitalism and Human Rights’’: The International is online
Own Correspondent//9:50am, Jun 20th '22

‘‘Inequality, Capitalism and Human Rights’’: The International is online

Grab your digital copy nowThe 21st issue of The International is already online with the theme "Inequality, Capitalism and Human Rights". The issues of human rights are all connected to the existence of....

Read More
Amazon, Starbucks say ‘get back’: Workers say fight back!
Steve Gillis Jim McMahan and Minnie Bruce Pratt//6:57am, Sep 27th '22

Amazon, Starbucks say ‘get back’: Workers say fight back!

Big Business would like to believe that the wave of class struggle by U.S. workers is fading — despite being so visible in Amazon Labor Union’s historic victory at the JFK8 warehouse in Staten Island,....

Read More
Media's Anti-China Propaganda Will Hurt Australia
Jerry Grey China//12:58am, Sep 30th '23

Media's Anti-China Propaganda Will Hurt Australia

It was OK with ASIO, the Defence Department, the Treasury Minister of the day (Scott Morrison) and it was definitely OK with the Northern Territory government to lease the Port of Darwin to a Chinese contractor.....

Read More
Unveiling True Nature of Victims of Communism
Tarik Ata Great Britain//10:34am, Aug 4th '21

Unveiling True Nature of Victims of Communism

The ‘Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation’ (VOC) is a Washington based organisation that states its purpose is "educating Americans about the ideology, history and legacy of communism." but obviously....

Read More
The Insurgency and Banditry Industry in Nigeria
Clarius Ugwuoha Nigeria//9:38pm, Mar 17th '21

The Insurgency and Banditry Industry in Nigeria

Boko Haram, loosely translated to mean, "Western Education is Forbidden," began their radical onslaught against the northern part of Nigeria and neighboring countries, first in ineffective cells, then....

Read More
ISRAEL: EUROPE WITHIN THE ORIENT
Sumedha Chatterjee Ireland//2:08am, May 18th '21

ISRAEL: EUROPE WITHIN THE ORIENT

Israel, touted as the only democracy in the West Asia cannot stay shrouded behind the same tag anymore. The whole world watched crowds dance gleefully to zochreini na. Perhaps the easiest way to evade....

Read More