19

Feb

12:55pm
Amiad Horowitz Vietnam
Sanctions only create suffering for poor people, so why keep imposing them?

Sanctions only create suffering for poor people, so why keep imposing them?

Amiad Horowitz Vietnam//12:55pm, Feb 19th '23

For decades, the United States government has used economic sanctions as a supposedly non-violent way of forcing supposed enemy states to capitulate to the will of the U.S. We are told that as opposed to open conflict, sanctions are less violent. At first glance, this might seem true… a more humane form of warfare, if there was such a thing. After all, stopping the import or export of certain goods certainly seems less violent than dropping bombs.

However, the truth is that sanctions are among the deadliest and most cruel weapons in the United States’ arsenal.

Sanctions are a means of economic warfare that, in most cases, specifically target the civilian population of a country. The goal is to make the lives of the people so miserable that they will rise up against their own government, hopefully leading to it being replaced by a new regime that is more amenable to U.S. desires.

There is no room to mince words here: Sanctions are a crime against humanity and a violation of international law. The Geneva Convention, the Nuremberg Convention, the United Nations Charter, and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights all prohibit the targeting of civilians.

Not only do sanctions target civilians, but they are also almost exclusively aimed at those civilians in some of the poorest developing countries. In other words, sanctions are designed to hurt those who are most vulnerable; they’re a tool of abject cruelty.

In fact, according to a 1999 article in the journal Foreign Policy, “Sanctions of Mass Destruction,” it was concluded that “sanctions have contributed to more deaths than all WMD (weapons of mass destruction) throughout history.” The number of sanctions has only increased since 1999, meaning the number of victims has only grown.

According to the anti-sanctions advocacy organization Sanctions Kill, the United States currently imposes sanctions on over 40 countries, affecting a third of humanity. Many of these countries, such as the Democratic Republic of Congo, South Sudan, and Somalia, are among the poorest countries in the world. Others, such as Libya, Syria, and Yemen, have been devastated by long wars—wars the United States is directly involved in perpetuating.

Sanctions target some of the most basic logistical and medical supplies needed in any modern functioning society. Supplies needed for sewage lines, elevators, construction materials, and electrical generators are just a few examples of the types of supplies the U.S. tries to stop from reaching countries under economic sanctions.

Although the U.S. government often says its sanctions are targeting foreign officials, businesspeople, or elites, the truth is that sanctions can’t differentiate between different segments of the population. In fact, they are most likely to hit the sick, the young, the elderly, and the poor the hardest. Sanctioned items often become only available for high prices on the black market. The rich and the ruling class of the sanctioned country—the people often responsible for whatever policy the U.S. objects to—will be able to get whatever they want and need, while the working class, the young, and the most disenfranchised suffer.

The current situation in Syria highlights the fact that the very goal of economic sanctions is cruelty for cruelty’s sake. Two weeks ago, southern Turkey and northern Syria were hit by a devastating 7.8 magnitude earthquake causing the deaths of tens of thousands of people and untold suffering. The international community has been gathering resources to help the victims, however, at least partially due to the sanctions imposed on Syria by the United States, much of the aid is prevented from reaching the victims in that country. (The Syrian government, with its own restrictions on port access, is worsening the situation as well.)

Many other governments have proposed that the U.S. temporarily lift the sanctions to allow aid to reach the earthquake victims. The U.S. government has only responded with a 180-day exemption to its sanctions on Syria for “all transactions related to earthquake relief efforts.” So in six months, the full economic offensive will be back in force.

Another important point to keep in mind in this discussion is that sanctions have never caused a population to rise up and replace their government. Cuba has been under economic sanctions for over 60 years, and its government is as stable as ever.

The very premise of economic sanctions assumes that the people suffering because of the United States’ economic warfare will blame their own government for their hardships. The assumption is that they will conclude their leaders shouldn’t have provoked the U.S. For sanctions to work, the victims would have to be stupid and not know the real source of their suffering. This is not the case, and so sanctions have never led to regime change.

Despite their ineffectiveness and illegality, sanctions continue to be one of the U.S. government’s favorite tools to project its power. U.S. imperialism continues to toss out sanctions as if they were free t-shirts at a sporting event, and as a result, hundreds of millions of people around the world continue to suffer.

Originally published in Peoples World

Caste, Community, and Farmers' Movements: A historical survey and analysis of farmers' movements in western UP
Shivam Mogha and Mahima Chouhan//12:33am, Nov 18th '21

Caste, Community, and Farmers' Movements: A historical survey and analysis of farmers' movements in western UP

'Kisan Mazdoor Ekta Zindabad' (Farmers-Labourers Unity Long Live) is reverberating as the popular slogan of the protesting farmers at the borders of Delhi. The call for unity is also being raised in the....

Read More
Sudan : Revolution until victory
Jad Kabbanji Lebanon//8:59pm, Nov 8th '21

Sudan : Revolution until victory

On December 19, we will commemorate the 3rd anniversary of the Sudanese uprising. This popular movement of unprecedented magnitude put an end to the obscurantist and anti-democratic regime of President....

Read More
UFPLA Uyghur forced Labor Prevention Act
Fernando Munoz Bernal Colombia//11:42am, Oct 24th '24

UFPLA Uyghur forced Labor Prevention Act

Between the months of April and August of last year, I drove my EV and trailer RV to more than 40 locations and 15,000 kilometres in the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region while I documented my experience.What....

Read More
Some brief comments about Brazil's current political situation
Guilherme Brendt Brazil//10:18pm, Oct 24th '21

Some brief comments about Brazil's current political situation

This article doesn’t intend to be a long and profound analysis in Brazil's political situation, but a short informative to introduce the main aspects, in a recent perspective, about Brazilian class struggle.....

Read More
Chile: 50 Years of Coup and Neoliberalism
Saheli Chowdhury India//2:06am, Sep 14th '23

Chile: 50 Years of Coup and Neoliberalism

One such day 50 years ago, a US-backed and funded military coup overthrew the first socialist president who had been elected through the “acceptable” path of bourgeois election, and drowned a country....

Read More
Georgi Dimitrov’s ‘‘United Front: The Struggle Against Fascism and War’’ and its Value for Our Moment - Part 1
Turner Roth USA//3:56pm, May 31st '23

Georgi Dimitrov’s ‘‘United Front: The Struggle Against Fascism and War’’ and its Value for Our Moment - Part 1

IntroductionIn a period of increasing tensions, where world powers, caught in the systemic compulsions of our contemporary capitalism dominated by the United States axis, draw closer to forms of world-historical....

Read More